When Should You Guess an Answer?
Updated 2026-11-15
Whether to guess is a probability question. If your chance of being right is above the break-even point, the question has a positive expected value.
The rule
Guess when P(correct) > negative ÷ (positive + negative)
This break-even probability is the same as break-even accuracy. Compute yours with the break-even accuracy calculator.
How many options must remain
So with a 1/2 penalty and four options, a blind guess is slightly negative (−0.125 marks per +1), but eliminating one option makes it neutral and eliminating two makes it positive (+0.25).
| Scheme | Break-even probability | Most options remaining for guessing to be at least neutral |
|---|---|---|
| 1/4 penalty | 20% | 5 |
| 1/3 penalty | 25% | 4 |
| 1/2 penalty | 33.3% | 3 |
Worked example
A 1/4 penalty at +4/−1 with 4 options: P(correct) = 0.25, so EV = 0.25 × 4 − 0.75 × 1 = +0.25. Remove one option and P = 1/3, so EV = 4/3 − 2/3 = +0.67. Try variations in the guessing probability calculator.
Cautions
- Expected value is an average. Over a few questions you can still lose marks.
- Your real chance matters, not your hope. If you are not sure why one option is better, treat it as a blind guess.
- The break-even rule assumes the remaining options are equally likely; real knowledge can make your odds better than that.
Try the calculators
Keep reading
This guide is general educational information. Marking schemes differ by exam and year, so confirm the rules in your official notification.